Love this place. Pizza and breadsticks are so yummy and worth the money. Every time i have gone in the staff is always friendly and attentive! Plenty of seats available!

Don't ever trust your boyfriend to order pizza! This man got 2 22" pizzas and when I tell you these pizzas are MASSIVE I'm not joking, the slices themselves are friggin huge! We also got cheese bread and bread sticks and the bread sticks are so big they fold them in half to put them in a box! The pizzas themselves were AMAZING definitely get the Vinny! Ricotta cheese on a pizza!? WHY HAVE I NEVER DONE THAT BEFORE!? IT'S SO GOOD! I will warn you if you get the 22" you will be eating it for DAYS it's huge! The cheese bread is really good too and they have a variety of sauces! We can't have bread sticks marinara let's be real if you're an out of towner like myself and love pizza you will definitely enjoy this place!

I came here with my friends for the first time after a concert, and this place was amazing!!! Despite there being a long line for the pizza, the line moved quickly, and the service was fantastic. Every slice of pizza was fresh and delicious, and the giant breadsticks were SO good! We are definitely stopping by again next time we're in the area.

We had an incredible experience at Goodfellas Pizza on Mass Ave! While the music was a bit loud, I’ve never felt more welcomed anywhere. We rolled in with a large group after a concert, and despite the late hour, Bree and the entire crew were exceptional. Their hospitality was truly second to none, making us feel right at home. Plus, the food was absolutely outstanding! I highly recommend this place for a fun night out. Thank you so much for a memorable evening!

Goodfellas absolutely Slapped. This is as close to NY Pizza that we have had here in Indy. It was our first time visiting and the staff was very nice. Explained how to order, and even cut our slices in 1/2 for us. Good music, clean environment very trendy. But forget all that we were here for the pizza and Goodfellas delivered. We will be back

Delicious crust and sauce. To be very clear, I had a rough night here, it took awhile to get our pizzas and we were starving, and my pizza was made wrong and had to be remade. And, I’m giving them 5 stars! To be fair, it was Saturday night and it was jam packed with pizzas flying everywhere and I am difficult with no cheese. Alex ate most of his sausage and cheese pizza and enjoyed the rest for breakfast. The staff was exceedingly nice and offered to make it right with a dessert etc. which I didn’t want. I enjoyed the vibes of the restaurant and the reaction in fixing the order was prompt and respectful. We both enjoyed our pizzas and highly recommend this as the spot for pizza in Indy!

We had a really great experience at Goodfellas on Mass Ave Memorial Day weekend. We needed to catch a quick bite so we specifically came in to get a large slice of pizza to tide us over. I was eyeing the pepperoni slice, but the sun-dried tomato and spinach looked ever so tempting, so I went with the latter and was very glad that I did!! What a treat!! It's made with a garlic sauce rather than a tomato base and it was really savory! The service here was exceptional. They really made us feel like part of the family. We'll definitely be coming back soon.

Never tried Goodfellas so we did this past Saturday and it was perfection! Everything was sooooo yummy. I loved the pizza, salad & the buffalo chicken cheese bread?! Can’t wait to order Goodfellas next time we have pizza!